Savor the Best Edgartown, MA Restaurants

Enjoy our In-House Offerings

From freshly caught lobster to decadent desserts, Martha's Vineyard dining is locally focused on what's fresh and in-season. Our on-site Edgartown, MA restaurants are true representatives of this philosophy. For Kelley House guests looking for Martha’s Vineyard restaurant recommendations, an array of choices sit steps from your door. The hotel operates two onsite dining venues, The Newes from America Pub and our newest addition, Wave Pool Bar

The Newes from America Pub

Named by Travel + Leisure as one of the best places to eat in Martha's Vineyard, this famous Colonial pub can be found at the base of The Kelley House in the heart of the village of Edgartown. Built in 1742, The Kelley House is one of the oldest buildings on Martha's Vineyard. This rich history and genuine Colonial character is most evident at The Newes with its original rough-hewn beams, ballast brick walls and warm hearth. Truly, this is a standout among Edgartown, MA restaurants.

The menu blends American and British pub food favorites, featuring local signatures such as Bangers & Mash, Roquefort Stilettos, and Martha's Vineyard's world-famous Fish & Chips. 

The Newes prides itself on offering some of the most highly rated, limited-release, New England draft beers. A Rack of Beers is available for sampling.

  • The pub welcomes diners of all ages with a Kid's Menu and micro-brewed draft root beer!
  • The Newes From America Pub is open daily.
    • Breakfast is served from 7:00 - 10:00 a.m.
    • Lunch & Dinner are served 11:30 a.m. - 10:00 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, 11:30 a.m. - 11:00 p.m. on Fridays & Saturdays
  • The Newes does not take reservations. See you there!

The Newes from America Menus:

Wave Pool Bar

Conveniently located next to the pool area of the Kelley House, Wave Bar includes relaxed outdoor seating in a garden atmosphere. Grab a bite to eat while enjoying a craft cocktail from our friendly bar staff and live music from local performers.

Wave Pool Bar Menu: